School of Advanced International StudiesJohns Hopkins University
The SAIS ReviewThe SAIS Review
History
Submissions
Issues and Articles
SAIS Students
About Us
Contact Us
Home
Full text of all articles is available in PDF and HTML formats at Project Muse
     Winter-Spring 2004, Volume 24, No. 1

 Smart Intelligence? 

Foreword

Domestic Perspectives

Intelligence for the Homeland

by Bruce Berkowitz

Two years after the September 11 attacks on America, a significant gap remains in our defenses against terrorists and other forms of foreign attack.  The problem is that we still lack adequate homeland intelligence.

Domestic Intelligence and Civil Liberties

by Kate Martin

There have been recent calls to substitute the "intelligence paradigm" for a "law enforcement paradigm" in domestic counterterrorism efforts.  While better information and analysis is needed to fight terrorism, there is reason to fear that transforming domestic counterterrorism primarily into an intelligence matter is unlikely to appreciably increase security, but will seriously threaten civil liberties.

It its Time to Transform, Not Reform U.S. Intelligence

by Deborah Barger

Many would argue that intelligence reform efforts have resulted in more regulation and bureaucracy and little, if any, improvement in intelligence performance.  To address the challenges that the United States will face in the future, it needs to look forward to transforming intelligence, not backwards at reforming it.

Terrorism, Intelligence, and Organized Crime

Untangling the Terror Web: Identifying and Counteracting the Phenomenon of Crossover Between Terrorist Groups

by Matthew Levitt

The war on terror will be most effective if it has a strategic focus on the full matrix of international terrorism rather than a tactical focus on al Qaeda.  Prosecuting the war on terror, whether on the battlefield or in the courtroom, demands greater attention to the web of interaction among these various groups and state sponsors.

Transnational Terror and Organized Crime: Blurring the Lines

by Thomas M. Sanderson

To circumvent the constricting impediments to financing terrorism, transnational terrorist organizatinos are moving deeper into organized criminal activity.  As terror groups transform into hybrid criminal/terror entities and partner with criminal syndicates, the threat to the United States and other nations rises in complexity, demanding a highly flexible, tailored response.

Photo Essay

"Mindanao on the Mend": Conflict and reconciliation in the Southern Philippines

by Ryan Anson

Global Intelligence and Foreign Liaisons

Intelligence Transformation and Intelligence Liaison

by Michael Warner

Liaison relationships were crucial to the constuction of a more modern American intelligence system during and just after World War II.  Charting these influences demonstrates how liaison contacts affect a developing intelligence structure, and suggests that the quality of contacts with foreign intelligence services affects not only the direction, but also the pace of intelligence modernization.

Interstate and Intrastate Dynamics in Southeast Asia's War on Terror

by See Seng Tan and Kumar Ramakrishna

Recent studies highlight the relative dearth of counterterrorism cooperation between member nations of the Association of Southeast Nations (ASEAN).  Acknowledging that more can and should be done by Southeast Asian governments in interdicting terrorism, the authors argue that collaboration between and among security and intelligence services of ASEAN and partner countries in the war on terror has been fairly effective.

Mexican Intelligence at a Crossroad

by Christopher Leroy

The presidential election victory of Vicente Fox in July 2000 ushered in hope for the reform of Mexico's intelligence community.  The slow pace of reform since then leaves much to be questioned.  An examination of the Center of Intelligence and National Security as well as other underlying problems afflicting the wider intelligence community in Mexico reveals the challenges and pitfalls that confronted early reform attempts by the Fox administration.

New Ways to Look at Old Threats

Bioterrorism as a Foreign Policy Issue

by Marc L. Ostfield

Bioterrorism, the intentional release of biological pathogens, is distinct from other forms of terrorism in several important ways.  This article details the differences that set bioterrorism apart, and discusses a number of implications for foreign policy decision makers, who ideally should be involved in planning for both the prevention of and response to bioterrorism.

Subjectivity of Intelligence Analysis and Implications for the U.S. National Security Strategy

by Kevin Russell

The language used to describe intelligence estimates as objective reflections of available evidence has led to a misunderstanding of the role of intelligence in supporting the decision to go to war in Iraq.  Saying that the estimate that identified the threat was either "right" or "wrong" ignores the probabilistic nature of intelligence assessments and the necessary subjective elements that make them useful to policymakers.

Reviews

Shock and Awe: Analyzing the War in Iraq

by Thomas G. Mahnken

review of Robert Scales' The Iraq War

The Great Equalizer

by Kerry M. Kartchner

review of Scott D. Sagan and Kenneth N. Waltz's The Spread of Nuclear Weapons

Intelligence and the Cold War

by Jerome Elie

review of Richard Aldrich's The Hidden Hand: Britain, America and the Cold War Secret Intelligence

Democracy in Africa: Women Need Not Apply?

by Jeffrey Krilla

review of essay collection No Shortcuts to Power: African Women in Politics and Policy Making

Corporate Peace?

by John Windmueller

review of Andreas Wegner and Daniel Moeckli's The Untapped Potential of the Business Sector

Whiteout

by Randolph T. Baron

review of Russell Crandall's Driven by Drugs: U.S. Policy Toward Colombia

Recent Books

Tomicah Tillemann on Madeline Albrights' Memoir; Andreas Hipple on economic sanctions; Katherine Shafer on foreign aid and governance; and Scott Featherston on the founding of the United Nations

Recommended Books

A compilation of the best books on intelligence, as suggested by this issue's contributing authors.

SAIS Review
1619 Massachusetts Avenue, NW   Washington, DC   20036-2213  
Voice: 202.663.5766   | Fax: 202.663.5769